June 24, 2010
The struggle was the dark side contrasting sharply with the bright and common theme of the exhibition -- animation. These artists, Kara Walker and Mary Reid Kelley were helping to open the show by discussing their work with the curators in front of the public. The 8th annual SITE Santa Fe Biennial, which opened June 20, is called Dissolve
Dissolve is Flickering Images in Dark Rooms.... yes, but more. Cartoons, colorful drawing, Pixar .... no. Citizen Cane, Gone with the Wind, Birth of a Nation ... colder, colder. Fantasia, spin art, Monty Python ... getting warmer. Video art is somewhere in the dark matter between Pixar and Pottery Barn, and Visual Genius is a struggle to see, for both for viewers and makers. It's easy to make (and get) something pleasant or cleaver. It's hard to go nebular.
On June 19, I listened to these artists talk about their struggle to make something meaningful, so on the first day of the public opening of Dissolve, I pledge to be open minded and see if I could get something (great, a gem, a tiny spark, a bubble) from this exhibition of non-stop video. In a museum where no silent still things compete with it. Great concept; what's there to see?
Airplanes fly across the screen that pretend to be drawn on a flipbook. Pretend. Not good enough. Hiraki Sawa. Thumbs down.
A toy car scene lays on a table. Video from four cameras is spliced together as if a automatic TV director is calling out 'close-up,' 'two-shot,' 'wide-shot,' ect. and this plays above the toy scene. The show is a traffic jam, we can tell by the sound of honking cars. A tiny, toy couple watch the jam up from park benches. The expression on their faces (close-up) is fascinatingly always the same.
Seeing film and the filmed at the same time is not often possible, but we know it exists. Jennifer and Kevin McCoy gives viewers the immediate experience of it.
A man dressed in tails drawing a picture on a large sketchpad. He draws a bottle of wine and a glass and then plucks the real think off the board. This film was made by the Edison Company to promote the idea of moving pictures sometime between 1894 and 1918. I can imagine the people who made this little old film, and I don't hear them talking like angst-driven artists. The image is fun to see. Its inclusion in this show is an attempt to put the struggle to make relevant video art in 2010 in historical perspective.
Jacco Olivier makes a finger painting, and another one, and another and links them together as a moving film with a similar plot to Avitar. Lush in color, it is less than 2 minutes long. We might not have criticized the story line if Avitar had been so short. (Same can be said for a few of the more narrative (not really fully narrative) videos in the rest of this show.)
A gem, with a few issues. Berni Searle lays a cut-out silhouette of three clumps of people in a tray of water and the red dye from the paper dissolves into the water in front of our eyes on three different large screens. You know you've seen this paper before. The texture is something you understand but can't quite explain. The bottom edge of the paper is crinkled and the figures seem to be standing in a natural landscape that's loosing all its color. One of the silhouette forms doesn't quite stand up. It flops onto the bulk of the paper. It confirms that the image was made with paper. The red dye leaves the paper and swirls around in the water until the whole scene starts over again. Better than a lava lamp.
I got sucked into watching an older woman in costumes of obvious types: nun, sailor, cowboy. These change every few minutes. She appeared to be singing something in German, a traditional folk song, maybe. The costumes related to drawings layered behind her, but I can't understand the German. There are a lot of people in this gauzy-green room, and four other videos demanding attention. I placed myself under the speaker and got lured into the singsong of the German woman. I try to make sense of the other works. Random images. Random narrative. Sure, there's some cool drawing, cool photo and digital images, but not much clarity.
Afraid I was going to miss some bits of genius due to overload-blackout, I decided to come back later. I wrote my prior post, which talks about the quick and easy pieces in this show, and 'later' turns out to be days later because SITE is only open Thursday through Sunday.
Three gems would have been missed if I hadn't come back ... William Kentridge. Watch someone draw, erase and redraw an image as it tells a story. Nothing like watching paint dry; it's beautiful; vivid gray smudges remind you of what was drawn like your dreaming it.
Cindy Sherman's short piece where her image is a paper doll in a package and she gets put in different costumes. Ahhhh....a breath of clarity.
And more clarity with Black Stuntman, an ordinary guy, facing ordinary troubles with a costume -- pencil drawn, of course.
Black Stuntman is one of several videos in a big square room. There is a big screen showing the work of one of the angst-filled women, the one who read a pun-filled poem called You Make Me Iliad, at the panel discussion, Mary Reid Kelley (see the first photo). The iambic pentameter poem is read for a camera by the serious voice of its creator. The look of this speaker and the other characters who represent German WWI soldiers reminded me of an old B&W cartoon of Mickey Mouse. And there were some films from that genre playing in the same room. About five on little airplane-like screens in front of the bench seating, so you could keep an eye on a little screen while watching the Iliad droning on. The make-up is interesting. The poem is nonsense. Cleaver figures of speech, alone, do not make exceptional poetry. Nor was this piece exceptional film making, acting, or .... unless I just missed it entirely ... visual art. Because you can illustrate the words, or animate the images, doesn't mean you should.
Just like any big 'biennial' art experience, there are always gems and klunkers, and there were some of each in each of the pieces I really took the time to look at in this show. There is stuff worth seeing, and I'm going to try to go back in and see more.
Terry Talty writes about the experience of being human and looking at contemporary art.























Recent Comments